Comparing Cargo Nets: Which Ones Can Hold It Together?

When it comes to securing your cargo, not all nets are created equal. If you want to keep your gear safe and your adventures stress-free, choosing the right type of cargo net is absolutely essential. Thankfully, with so many different nets available, there's an option to suit every need. Lets check out some of our favorite cargo nets here at etrailer, and help you figure out the ideal match for your cargo needs.

Mesh and Tarp-Style Nets: Built for Strength and Stability

If you’re hauling heavier gear or need extra security on the road, mesh and tarp-style cargo nets are definitely the way to go. These nets offer more durability than elastic cord alternatives, and feature either cam buckles or straps for a tighter, more reliable hold. However, they do tend to run a bit more expensive, but that’s just part of paying for that superior dependability.

1. The Benton HotMesh Cargo Net

The Benton HotMesh Cargo Net is our top choice when it comes to Cargo Nets. A standout option for securing gear on hitch-mounted cargo carriers, it combines the security of a cargo net, ratchet straps, and a tarp into one convenient package.

Why It's Our Top Choice:

Key Features:

Strength and Durability: The HotMesh combines the stability of ratchet straps with the wrap-around security of a net.
Added Protection: The reinforced mesh offers a degree of tarp-like coverage, minimizing shifting and shielding your gear from light debris.
Convenient Storage: When not in use, the HotMesh folds neatly into its built-in storage bag, ensuring it’s tangle free and ready for your next trip.

Strengths:

Perfect Fit for Hitch-Mounted Carriers: Unlike larger nets (like the Gladiator Utility Cargo Net, which can be bulky or oversized for standard cargo carriers) the HotMesh is purpose-built for a precise fit.
Ease of Use: Thanks to its integrated straps and built-in tension system, the Benton HotMesh gives you even, unwavering tension across your load. So you never have to worry about pulling over to re-tighten your straps.
Versatility for Smaller Loads: While it’s not as large as some heavy-duty options, its compact size makes the HotMesh perfect for everyday hauls and weekend adventures.

Weaknesses:

Limited Application: Its tailored fit for 24”x60” hitch-mounted carriers makes the HotMesh less versatile for larger setups (like truck beds or ATVs).

2. The Gladiator Utility Cargo Net with Cam Buckle Tie-Downs

The Gladiator Utility Cargo Net is another very rugged choice. Its 4'x4' rip-stop mesh design and cam buckle tie-downs make it excellent for demanding tasks like hauling gear on ATVs, rooftop cargo baskets, or even in the back of your vehicle. This net is built for heavy-duty use, and is more than capable of hauling bulky and awkwardly shaped gear, like backpacks, coolers, and totes.

Strengths:

Exceptional Durability: Engineered for tough conditions, this net is built to last, even with frequent use.
Secure Fit for Heavy Loads: The cam buckle tie-downs provide superior hold and adjustability compared to standard hooks, keeping even the heaviest items in place.
Large Coverage Area: The 4' x 4' size ensures excellent coverage for larger setups, reducing the need for multiple nets or additional tie-downs.
Multi-Use Versatility: Suitable for a variety of vehicles and cargo setups, from off-road ATVs, to truck beds, rooftop cargo baskets, and even in the back of your SUV.

Weaknesses:

Heavier and Bulkier: While the sturdy design is great for security, its size and weight make the Gladiator Cargo Net less convenient to handle or store, compared to lighter nets.
Overkill for Smaller Loads: This is a larger net, so it may be excessive for lighter, less demanding cargo.
Higher Price Point: The Gladiator Cargo Net comes with a premium price point to match its high-quality features.

Elastic Cord Nets: Lightweight and Convenient

For lighter loads or occasional use, elastic cord cargo nets are a budget-friendly solution. While they won’t offer the same durability as mesh or tarp nets, their stretchy construction and ease of use make them versatile and convenient for a number of applications.

3. The Curt Stretchable Cargo Net

The Curt Stretchable Cargo Net is a smaller cargo net, designed to keep items secure in hitch-mounted cargo carriers, rooftop baskets, and truck beds. While it only measures 43”x24”, this net is super stretchy and can work with cargo carriers up to 60” long. The flexible elastic cording also means it can accommodate bulky and irregularly-shaped cargo with ease. Equipped with multiple plastic hooks, it ensures quick attachment without scratching your vehicle or carrier.

Strengths:

Versatility: Fits a range of cargo carriers and rooftop baskets, accommodating many different cargo sizes.
Elasticity: The stretchy cords provide a snug fit, keeping items in place during transit.
User-Friendly Hooks: Plastic hooks allow for quick and easy attachment, and prevent damage to your vehicle or carrier.

Weaknesses:

Durability Concerns: Some users have mentioned that the plastic hooks may not withstand heavy use over time, and elastic cords can wear out and stretch with regular use.
Size Limitations: May not provide enough coverage for larger cargo loads due to its smaller dimensions.

4. The Reese Stretchable Cargo Net

The Reese Stretchable Cargo Net offers similar features to the Curt net but with slightly larger dimensions, making it better suited for medium-sized loads. Measuring 36”x48”, this net can accommodate most cargo sizes, and works with virtually any type of carrier. The large plastic hooks are easy to handle, allowing for simple and speedy attachment.

Strengths:

Adjustability: Elastic cording stretches to accommodate various cargo sizes, providing a customizable fit.
Quick Attachment: Large hooks allow for quick and easy attachment to different anchor points.
Compatibility: Works with virtually any carrier

Weaknesses:

Hook Durability: Similar to the Curt and Thule cargo nets, the plastic hooks may be prone to wear and breakage under heavy loads.
Elastic Wear: Over time, the elastic material may lose its stretch, allowing cargo to slip and slide around.

5. The Thule Cargo Net with Storage Bag

The Thule Cargo Net is a premium elastic cord option, offering a balance of convenience and quality. Measuring 40”x36”, this premium net comes with extra-large hooks and durable shock cords to keep your gear safe and in place. It’s an ideal size for most cargo carriers, especially rooftop cargo baskets. Thanks to its high quality construction, as well as the included storage bag, the Thule Cargo net is a step above the other elastic nets in its category.

Strengths:

High-Quality Materials: Thule is known for durable and reliable products, and this net is no exception.
Large Hooks: The extra-large hooks make it easy to attach the net, even with gloved hands.
Storage Convenience: The included storage bag helps keep the net organized when not in use.

Weaknesses:

Higher Price: Thule products often come at a premium price point compared to other brands, and this net is no exception.
Size Constraints: The net's dimensions may not be suitable for larger cargo setups like truck beds.
Elastic Durability Concerns: Despite the higher quality of construction compared to other nets in this category, the Thule Cargo Net is still an elastic net, and will eventually stretch out with use and abuse.

If you’re looking for the most durable and secure option, the Benton HotMesh Cargo Net is the standout choice. Its reinforced design and integrated straps make it perfect for serious adventurers and tailgaters alike. For those needing a more all-terrain friendly solution, the Gladiator Utility Cargo Net is another excellent option, especially for larger loads.

If lightweight and affordable are more your style, consider the Curt or Reese Stretchable Cargo Nets for everyday use. And if you want something lightweight, but a bit more premium, the Thule Cargo Net combines convenience with quality. No matter which net you choose, investing in the right gear is sure to make all your adventures smoother, safer, and more enjoyable.

About Izzy B.

My journey with etrailer has had a number of twists and turns. I first started here in 2019 as a Summer Intern with our Content Department. I ended up enjoying the experience so much, that I came back to work at etrailer during several academic breaks throughout my college years. After some time away, I returned last Spring to work at our main warehouse, first as a Picker, and eventually on our Audit Team. Then, at the start of 2024, I was offered the chance to come aboard etrailer's Marketing Department, as a Writer for the Shopping Guide Team. Now, I help our neighbors by creating informational content to aid their shopping experience, ensuring they find the info, products, and solutions they need to get their own journeys underway!