Can I Use 4,000 lbs Springs to Replace 3,500 lbs Leaf Springs?
Updated 12/02/2025 | Published 11/04/2025
Products Featured in This Question
Question:
Question regarding e57SR 4,000Lb leaf spring. Id like to know if these are a compatible spring for my trailer. Trailer is 2022 Jayco Jayfeather with dual Dexter 3500lb axles. In May of 2024, after finding the original springs flat, I replaced them with e54SR 3500lb springs, LC279687 Equalizers and wetbolt kit upon etrailers recommendation. Those replacements are now flat after about 10k miles. I have weighed the trailer several times over the last year and Im always within the max GVWR of 7250lbs. I would like to find a slightly more robust spring than the 3500lb that is compatible with my axles and equalizers without getting too stiff. Thank you.
asked by: Jason F
Expert Reply:
Hey Jason, welcome back! The 3-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 4,000-lb Trailer Axles item # e57SR is the same length so it would definitely work. Bumping up an extra 500 lbs per spring is definitely going to help with the longevity of your suspension. That increase in capacity along with you dropping down a leaf won't make your suspension stiff. The Dexter item # DX35CR would be a better replacement option though. Dexter's leaf springs are a higher quality and will last longer.
Please note that it is recommended to replace your suspension hardware item # MR46ZR, and your u-bolts item # CE23002 when you replace your springs. The bolts are only designed to be torqued down once.
What kind of roads are your traveling on? That seems awfully fast to wear out a set of springs traveling on highways.
You can add this information and any other questions you have where it says Reply to Jerred H and I'll be happy to answer them.
(click to enlarge)
Product Page this Question was Asked From
4-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 3,500-lb Trailer Axles - 25-1/4" Long
- Trailer Leaf Springs
- Double Eye Springs
- 9/16 Inch Eye
- Nylon Bushings
- 3500 lbs
- 1-3/4 Inch Wide
- 4 Leaf
- 25-1/4 Inch Long
- Standard Grade
- etrailer
more information >
Continue Researching
- Search Results: trailer leaf springs
- Search Results: 3500 lbs trailer leaf springs
- Shop: 3-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 4,000-lb Trailer Axles - 25-1/4" Long
- Search Results: 1~3/4 inch wide trailer leaf springs
- Search Results: trailer suspension parts
- Search Results: morryde`s suspension upgrade kit
- Shop: MORryde Suspension Upgrade Kit for Tandem Axle Trailers - 2-1/4" Long Shackle Straps
- Shop: 4-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 3,500-lb Trailer Axles - 25-1/4" Long
- Search Results: roadmaster comfort ride
- Shop: CE Smith U-Bolt Kit for Mounting 3,500-lb, Round Trailer Axles - 5-1/2" Long U-Bolts - Zinc
- Shop: 3-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 4,000-lb Trailer Axles - 25-1/4" Long
- Q&A: Do I Need to Get the Roadmaster Comfort Ride System with Shocks and Springs
- Search Results: shock kits
- Shop: 4-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 4,000-lb Trailer Axles - 26" Long
- Shop: Roadmaster Comfort Ride Shock Absorbers for Tandem Axle Trailers - 5,200-lb to 7,000-lb Axle
- Q&A: 2,000 lb Rated Leaf Spring Replacement For A Dexter 072-042-00
- Q&A: Replacement Springs and Hardware for 2011 Keystone Montana 3585SA
- Video: Terran Industries Trailer Suspension - Insider Insights
- Q&A: Will Roadmaster Comfort Ride Shock Absorbers Improve Ride With AllTrek 4000 Installed
- Q&A: How to Install Lippert Bolt-On Shock Mount Kit LC281255
- Video: All You Need to Know About the 3-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 4,000-lb Trailer Axles
- Video: Review of Redline Dust Cap Driver Tool - 290-992
- Q&A: Best Suspension Upgrade for 33" Tandem Axles: Road Armor vs Dexter EZ Flex for Ember 22ETS
- Q&A: Recommended 26" Long 4-Leaf Double Eye Leaf Spring for a 4,000 lbs Axle on a Boat Trailer
- Video: Review of TruRyde Trailer Leaf Springs - Double Eye Springs - TRU85FR
- Video: 4-Leaf Double-Eye Spring for 4,000-lb Trailer Axles Spec Review
- Article: What is the Best Trailer or RV Storage Cover
- Video: Review of EMCO Trailer Leaf Springs - 3 Leaf Double Eye Spring 4000 lbs Trailer Axle - EM98RB
- Video: Review of EMCO Trailer Leaf Springs - 4 Leaf Double Eye Spring 3500 lbs Trailer Axle - EM88UJ
- Shop: Front Mount Hitch
on Trailer Leaf Springs
Jerred H.
12/1/2025
Hey Jason, how did things go after switching to the 4,000‑lb springs on your Jayco Jayfeather? Did the new setup improve the ride and hold up better on your trips? Your update could really help others dealing with worn‑out leaf springs.