Enclosed Hitch Cargo Box vs Cargo Basket and Bag for Luggage
Updated 10/17/2026 | Published 10/16/2026
Products Featured in This Question
Question:
We take several family road trips each year, and with the third row up there's hardly any room for suitcases. Our SUV has a 2" hitch, so I'm deciding between an enclosed cargo box and a regular basket with a cargo bag. Is the hard box worth the extra money?
asked by: Jennifer C
Expert Reply:
Hey Jennifer! For maximum protection, I'd recommend the Thule Arcos XL Enclosed Cargo Carrier # TH528KQ. Its weather-resistant hard shell helps protect your luggage from the elements, and the built-in locks are nice for some extra peace of mind when you stop along the way. You get 15.9 cubic feet of storage with a 110 lb cargo capacity.
If that extra protection isn't a major concern, or you're looking to save some money, I'd go with the Benton MoveHitch Cargo Carrier # B86VR and etrailer Cargo Bag # 988501. The bag gives you 20 cubic feet of water-resistant storage, and you can remove it to use the basket for bulkier camping gear. I'd also add the etrailer Anti-Rattle Locking Hitch Pin # e43JR to keep it secure.
Where are you headed next?
(click to enlarge)
(click to enlarge)
Product Page this Question was Asked From
Benton MoveHitch 60x24 Cargo Carrier for 2" Hitches - Aluminum - Folding - 500 lbs
- Hitch Cargo Carrier
- Flat Carrier
- Folding Carrier
- Tilting Carrier
- Hitch Mount
- 500 lbs
- Fits 2 Inch Hitch
- 60 Inch Long
- Cargo
- Generators
- Aluminum
- Benton
more information >
Featured Help Information
Instructions
Continue Researching
- Q&A: Was Strength Testing Performed On Benton MoveHitch
- Q&A: Availability of Quick Release Hitch Pin for 24x60 etrailer Cargo Carrier
- Q&A: Cargo Carrier That Tilts For Easier Unloading
- Q&A: Aluminum Cargo Carrier Upgrade for Coastal Areas
- Q&A: Reliability of Benton MoveHitch Push-Button Release and Warranty
- Q&A: Can the Benton HotMesh Cargo Net Stretch Over Large Camping Gear?
- Q&A: Are Benton Cargo Carrier Tray and Modular Rack Available Without Shank
- Article: Best Hitch Cargo Carriers
- Article: Hitch Mounted Cargo Carrier Information
- Article: How to Choose a Cargo Carrier That Will Clear a Rear Mounted Spare Tire or Bumper
- Article: Trash your Ratchet Straps: 6 Ways Benton’s HotMesh Keeps Your Cargo Safer
- Article: Hitch Anti-Rattle Devices: The Ultimate Guide
- Article: Do You Need a Heat Shield for Air Bags?
- Article: What Do I Need To Tow A Trailer?
Jennifer
10/17/2026
We're heading to the Smoky Mountains for fall break. I'm leaning toward the Benton since we could use it for camping gear too, not just luggage.