Looking For A Replacement Toilet For My Thetford 42050 Toilet
Updated 12/08/2025 | Published 11/20/2025
Products Featured in This Question
Question:
I need to replace a Thetford 42050 Toilet. It appears that specific model number is no longer available. What are the direct replacements for that model? I have a Jayco 286BHSW. Let me know my options without making any modifications. Thanks
asked by: David P
Expert Reply:
Hey David,
It looks like that Thetford is their Aqua Magic II model. We do not have a "direct" replacement for that specific model number you gave however we do have that same style toilet. There are 2 options based on your rough-in measurement. This is the measurement form the wall to the center of the floor flange. If yours is a 9-1/2" you will want to go with # TH65SE, if it comes out to be 11" you will need # TH59SE
These are both standard height, round ceramic bowls in that same Aqua Magic style of yours.
Product Page this Question was Asked From
Thetford Aqua-Magic Style II Part-Timer RV Toilet - Standard Height - Round Bowl - Bone Ceramic
- RV Toilet
- Standard Height
- Round
- Slow Close Lid
- 9-1/2 Inch Rough-In
- Gravity Flush Toilet
- Triple Jet - Good
- Ceramic
- Off-White
- Thetford
more information >
Featured Help Information
Instructions
Continue Researching
- Search Results: ceiling panel
- Search Results: j~wrap
- Shop: Trailer Hitch
- Search Results: k23~180
- Search Results: furrion water heater door
- Q&A: Replacement Hot Water Heater for Dometic GC6AA -10E
- Search Results: cooktop
- Search Results: rv fender
- Search Results: rv panel
- Shop: Trailer Wiring
- Shop: Dexstar Steel Spoke Trailer Wheel - 15" x 5" Rim - 5 on 4-1/2 - Silver Powder Coat
- Shop: Revive RV Ceiling Kit - 400 sq ft - 100' x 4' Roll - Pebbled White
- Shop: Revive RV Ceiling Kit - 400 sq ft - 100' x 4' Roll - Arctic White
- Shop: Revive Peel-and-Stick RV Wallpaper Kit - 200 sq. ft. - 100' x 2' Roll - Crisp Linen
- Shop: Revive RV Ceiling Kit - 200 sq ft - 100' x 2' Roll - Arctic White
- Shop: Thetford Aqua-Magic Style II Part-Timer RV Toilet - Standard Height - Round Bowl - Bone Ceramic
- Shop: Furrion RV Tankless Water Heater - 60,000 Btu - 16" x 16" Door
- Video: Hands-On with the LaSalle Bristol Swivel Adapter for RV Sink Strainer
- Video: LaSalle Bristol Swivel Adapter for RV Sink Strainer Spec Review
- Q&A: Is the Dometic 310 Toilet the Same as the Powermax 310 Toilet?
- Q&A: How to Remove Old Slide Out Seal Adhesive Before Steele Rubber Seal Installation
- Q&A: What is the Difference Between the Curt Rockerball # C40047 and # CU46FR?
- Q&A: Will Dometic 410 RV Toilet DMC44JF Be A Good Fit For A 2020 Grand Design 320g Main Bathroom?
- Q&A: Replacement RV Toilet for Keystone Montana to Replace Dometic 310
- Q&A: Can Thetford Aqua-Magic Residence RV Toilet Replace Thetford Bravura
- Article: How Does an RV Toilet Work?
- Article: Which RV Propane Tank Size Do I Need?
- Article: RV Pre-Departure Checklist
- Article: Hitch Mounted Cargo Carrier Information
- Article: Trailer Wiring Diagrams
Nick S.
12/8/2025
Hey David, how did things go with measuring the rough-in for your Jayco’s toilet replacement? Were you able to find that one of the Aqua Magic options fit without any changes? Your update could make it easier for others replacing the same Thetford model.