Can I Replace One Damaged Tire on an Axle or Do I Need to Replace Both Tires?

Updated 03/26/2025 | Published 03/21/2025

Question:

I had an almost new late 2023 Goodyear Endurance ST225/75/15 E trailer tire get a bad puncture. It’s opposite side on the axle has 7.5/32” tread. Is it ok to put a new replacement tire 8/32”? on the same axle as the one with 7.5/32”?

asked by: Albert T

Expert Reply:

Yes, you can that won't be an issue Albert. Sorry, to hear about your troubles. The closest comparable option I have to a Goodyear Endurance is the Castle Rock ST225/75R15 Radial Trailer Tire item # 274-000029.

What did you run over?

expert reply by: Jerred H