Why Are The Factory Tires on My Trailer Rated for Less Than the GVWR
Question:
I own a 2016 Shasta Oasis 18BH SINGLE axle. It has a dry weight of 3288lbs and a max vehicle rating of 3832lbs. After accounting for the added weight of gear that I presume is not factored into the manufactures dry weight” and is also not my own personal gear e.g., propane tank, interstate battery, 2 tires and a spare tire, etc., and then adding on the personal items, the trailer weighed in at 4100lbs on a CAT scale at a truckstop of note, fresh, black, and grey and hot water tanks had been emptied. My new tires Carlisle HD 205/75R14 are rated at 2040lbs max single load. This means that the max weight the tires on my trailer should carry, per the recommendation, is 4040lbs. My max trailer weight is 3832lbs, and I am currently pulling 4100lbs. Now, besides the fact that I find it dubious that the dry weight is actually 3288lbs as it is highly unlikely I have 812lbs of personal gear in my trailer Im in the Marine Corps and definitely know how to travel light, I am trying to figure out how one can find a tire that safely pulls this trailer. By its design meaning a single axle with only 14inch tires one will almost always be pulling the maxed out weight on Load Rating C and D tires. Amazingly, it came with Load Range C tires which cant tow the max trailer rating of 3832lbs, so I upgraded to the Carlisle Load Range D. Even with this upgrade, this is still not enough, in my opinion. There is absolutely no room for safety buffer. I am astonished that this trailer is built, stock, to essentially max out 14inch tire Load Ranges, and equally astonished that it came with a Load Range C tire that carries a combined max weight of 3640lbs, which as stated, cant even carry the trailers max rating of 3832lbs how they sell a trailer with tires that cant even carry the max recommended payload is beyond me! That said, I have placed a 15inch tire on a rim next to the 14inch rim. There is absolutely no way a 15inch tire can fit I even found rub spots on the 14inch tire, meaning it had already made contact with the fender. Is there any tire out there that has a higher load rating to more safely pull my loaded trailer? Or, is there a way to modify it to install a 15inch tire with a higher Load Range? Thank you for your time!
asked by: Justin P
Expert Reply:
When it comes to load capacity, we typically just try to make it easy by recommending trailer tires that provide a combined load capacity that meets or (ideally) exceeds the trailer's loaded weight. With that being said when technicalities are brought in, it is important to note that 10 to 15 percent of the trailer's weight comes as tongue weight that's being applied to the tow vehicle. This means that in reality just about 3,257 to 3,448 pounds (using the trailer's 3,832 pound GVWR) of your trailer's weight is actually coming down on the tires.
Some trailer manufacturers do use this number to determine the proper tire and axle ratings, which certainly cuts it close in terms of capacity but is technically still safe and correct.
If you would like a bit more room for error, which I certainly understand and recommend, I recommend taking a look at the Kenda Karrier ST205/75R14 # AM10235. This particular Load Range D tire has a bit more capacity than the other options with a maximum load of 2,200 at 75 psi. It also has an excellent speed rating of 81 mph.
Now as for the loaded trailer weight I do have to recommend trying to unload some items to try and get it under the listed GVWR. Exceeding this number could down the line start to cause issues with the axle or suspension.

Products Referenced in This Question
Karrier ST205/75R14 Radial Trailer Tire - Load Range D
- Trailer Tires and Wheels
- Tire Only
- Radial Tire
- Load Range D
- 205/75-14
- 14 Inch
- M - 81 mph
- Kenda
more information >
Product Page this Question was Asked From
Kenda 4.80-12 Bias Trailer Tire with 12" White Wheel - 5 on 4-1/2 - Load Range C
- Trailer Tires and Wheels
- Tire with Wheel
- Bias Ply Tire
- Load Range C
- 4.80-12
- 12 Inch
- 5 on 4-1/2 Inch
- Steel Wheels - Powder Coat
- Kenda
more information >
Featured Help Information
Miscellaneous Media
Continue Researching
- Q&A: How to Select Trailer Tires with Correct Load Range Rating for Trailer Gross Weight
- Q&A: Which is Better for Highway Use 4.80-12 or 5.30-12 Trailer TIres
- Article: Trailer Tire Sizing
- Q&A: Is There Smaller 12 inch Trailer Tire that is Radial
- Q&A: Fastest Tires for a Malone Kayak Trailer
- Q&A: What is the Difference Between Load Range B and C Trailer Tires
- Article: 7 Common Questions Everyone Has About Trailer Tires
- Q&A: Increasing Wheel/Tire Size on Carry-On Utility Trailer
- Q&A: Repair Kit for Ram Series 12000 Trailer Jack
- Article: Our Team Picked The Best Camping Gear of the Year - Here Are Their Top Choices
- Article: Boat Trailer Guides: Which are the Best?
- Article: How to Launch a Boat from a Trailer (And Load it Back Up)
- Article: How to Measure Your Trailer Wheel Bolt Pattern
- Article: Most Popular Wheel Bearings