Which Cargo Box is More Aerodynamic? The Yakima CBX XXL or the Thule Motion 3?

Updated 12/14/2025 | Published 12/13/2025

Products Featured in This Question

Thule Motion 3 Rooftop Cargo Box - 21 cu ft - Black Glossy

(10)

$1249.95

Yakima CBX XXL Rooftop Cargo Box - 21.5 Cubic Ft - Glossy Black

(1)

$1212.32

Question:

I have a 2025 Nissan armada. Im looking for a Cargo Carrier for my roof. I am considering Thule Motion 3 or the Yakima CBX XXL. Are they both compatible with my stock cross bars? Do you recomend one or the other? Is one more sturdy than the other? My previous car carrier shook when I drove 70+ mph.

asked by: Jonathan C

Expert Reply:

Hey Jonathon. Both the Yakima CBX XXL item # Y73QD and the Thule Motion 3 item # TH59PN are going to work with your 2025 Nissan Armada's factory crossbars.

I recommend the Yakima CBX XXL Rooftop Cargo Box item # Y73QD. It's been specifically designed to match a large storage capacity with aerodynamics. The shorter wider profile and angles are designed to push air over and around the box.

What cargo box did you used to have?

You can add this information, along with any other questions you have, where it says Reply to Jerred H.

expert reply by: Jerred H

Yakima CBX XXL
(click to enlarge)

Jonathan C.

12/13/2025

I had an old Thule I don't know the model. I'm good with either of the two I just want your opinion on which one you think is the better rooftop and more robust (less flex). As I drive fast and I don't like seeing the rooftop carrier wobble. Thanks.

Jerred H.

12/14/2025

@JonathanC You're welcome! It's a close comparison that's for sure. The Yakima CBX XXL item # Y73QD is the better option as far as strength in design and aerodynamic advantage. It won't slow you down or shake you off the road.

Helpful Links

tv-quick-look-at-yakima-cbx-lg-rooftop-cargo-box-y63qd.aspx