Comparing the Thule Force XT and Motion XT Cargo Boxes for a 2015 Audi Q5

Updated 01/29/2020 | Published 05/01/2017

Question:

I have a 2015 Audi Q5 and am considering a cargo box. Is the Thule Force XL a better value over the Thule Motion XT XL? What advantages does the Thule Motion XT have over other cargo boxes? Did the Thule Motion XL replace the Thule Sonic line? Do you have any cargo box recommendations for the Audi Q5? Thanks for your time.

asked by: Matt W

Expert Reply:

The Thule Motion line of boxes including # TH629806 did replace the Sonic line but the design of the Motion is more angular. This is a premium box whereas the Force XT line including # TH6358B is a lower cost line. The locking/handle mechanisms are upgraded on the Motion as well.

The Force XT box is still an excellent cargo box and if I were choosing between it and the Motion I would probably go with the Force XT because you aren't giving up all that much if you do.

expert reply by: Michael H

Matthew

1/28/2020

Is the plastic on either stronger? I want something that is less likely to break if Im on rougher roads with my Jeep

Jacob H.

1/29/2020

Both of the roof boxes are going to be constructed of a durable ABS plastic. So they will have the same construction. If I were you and you were planning on taking your Jeep off-road, I would get the # TH6358B be cause it is going to resist scratches more than that of the # TH6298B with the gloss finish.