Choosing Between Yakima SwingDaddy 4 Bike Rack # Y02422 and Thule Vertex # TH9031

Expert Reply:

The two racks are very similar, but they have a few differences. Although they weigh about the same, the Thule Vertex, part # TH9031, has a higher weight capacity than the Yakima SwingDaddy, part # Y02422. The Vertex can carry 140 pounds, while the SwingDaddy can handle 120lbs. The Vertex has a longer shank, which would place the rear of the upright portion of the rack approximately 14 inches away from the hitch pin hole in the receiver, versus 11 inches for the SwingDaddy.

Both racks are very good products from a couple of top-drawer companies. Either rack would serve you very well. I prefer the more modern looking design of the Vertex, but if you do not need the additional length of the shank or the higher weight capacity, the SwingDaddy would work great for you. It also has the benefit of the integrated bottle opener for that after-ride refreshment.

You can take a look at the installation instructions for both bike racks, as well as a video review for each at the following links.

expert reply by: Mike L